World history has garnered significant interest among scholars, evident from the multitude of books and articles published on the subject. Braudel endeavors to analyze how the history of humanity evolves holistically, focusing on the concepts of civilization and geographic factors rather than adhering to chronological events. Influenced by the Annales school, which advocated a new form of history emphasizing ordinary people’s lives over leaders, and delving into aspects like climate, demography, agriculture, commerce, technology, transportation, and communication instead of traditional politics, diplomacy, and warfare, Braudel offers an in-depth examination of the inner mechanisms and political economy of various civilizations. Drawing from disciplines such as psychology, sociology, geography, and economics, Braudel’s definition of civilization distinguishes it from culture, noting how cultures can spread rapidly while civilizations encompass the dominant mentality of an era, often entrenched in religion. This mentality, rooted in historical origins and shaped by geography and past experiences, serves as the most resistant aspect of societal change.
The book comprises three chapters: “A History of Civilization,” “Civilizations Outside Europe,” and “European Civilizations.” The first chapter delineates civilization’s definition and understanding, while the second chapter, the most original part of the book, delves into Islamic, African, and East Asian civilizations. The final part focuses on European and American societies.
Braudel, adopting a materialistic approach to civilization’s definition, criticizes traditional history’s event-centric approach and advocates for understanding the underlying societal, geographic, economic, and mental factors shaping historical outcomes. He emphasizes the importance of historical understanding for comprehending the present.
In his exploration, Braudel elucidates the emergence and usage of the concept of “civilization,” its relationship with culture, and its contextualization within spaces, societies, economies, and common mentalities. He posits civilization as a set of values regulated by economic structures, shaped by people’s struggles with these values, leading to diverse institutions and lifestyles across civilizations.
According to Braudel, history does not progress linearly but varies based on temporal and geographical factors. He underscores the significance of geography, alongside society and individuals, in shaping civilizations, echoing Ibn Khaldun’s view that “geography is destiny.” Braudel observes geography’s profound impact on civilizations, exemplified by Egypt’s success in adapting to the Nile Valley’s conditions.
The second part of the book explores societies beyond Europe, albeit from a European-centric perspective. Braudel examines the Islamic world, the Far East, and Africa, analyzing Islam’s role as a mediator between Western and Eastern civilizations. He suggests a modernization model for Islamic societies while acknowledging colonial contributions but arguably from a Eurocentric standpoint.
Discussing Far Eastern societies, Braudel highlights social immobility and the role of religion in state-individual relationships. He observes hierarchical structures based on education among mandarins in China, contributing to its unique civilization.
In the final chapters, Braudel focuses on European civilizations, emphasizing economic relations and capitalism as drivers of modernization.
While Braudel adeptly elucidates geographical similarities between civilizations, his analysis overlooks the modifying power of institutions. Nevertheless, the book provides a comprehensive understanding of civilization’s main dynamics and tendencies.
One notable strength is Braudel’s fluid writing style, making complex concepts accessible while incorporating contemporary details and engaging anecdotes. His narrative vividly portrays historical characters and events, offering readers a nuanced understanding of societal changes and ruptures.
In conclusion, Braudel’s “Comparative Politics: A Developmental Approach” offers a compelling exploration of civilization’s evolution, shedding light on the interplay between geography, society, and culture in shaping human history.
Republic 